Between Tools and Reactions

Following the Elephant’s Trunk and Cups experiments, we explored possible directions through feedback review, brainstorming, and Crazy 8s. Two main ideas emerged: one focused on refining the tool-based device, and the other on an installation using chain reactions.

Previously, we used cup-shaped, low-fidelity devices prioritising sound and ease of use. This time, we proposed designs that move beyond the cup, such as devices where breath triggers visible particles or sound, or structures that function like wind instruments. Ideas also included a breath focus kit for daily use or installations in public spaces to support mindful breathing.

This direction helps users sense the rhythm of breath and connect internal states with external environments, similar to meditation. But, as seen in the cup test, analogue tools have limits in amplifying subtle signals like breath, and the experience can feel too brief or personal.

In response to the brief’s focus on aesthetic experience and brain activation, we explored a chain reaction system inspired by Rube Goldberg machines. A breath could trigger balls, bells, and more in a visual and playful sequence.

While this offers multi-sensory delight, interaction tends to end after activation, raising the question of how to sustain engagement beyond watching the outcome.

To clarify, I mapped our ideas in a design matrix crossing aesthetic experience and daily life with amplify and breath:

These gaps suggest room for new directions. Context matters, too – when and where does breath become meaningful?

We need to define who the user is and what scenario fits best.

We struggled to choose between the tool-based and installation-based paths. I leaned towards translating breath into other senses, while others preferred the chain reaction aesthetic. Eventually, we saw the need to either commit or find overlap. Both ideas had solid logic and appeal, making the decision tough.

At the midpoint presentation, feedback from Kinda Studios and peers highlighted the unfamiliar, analogue nature of the Elephant’s Trunk. Suggestions included blow pen-based art activities and breath-driven multiplayer games. We were also encouraged to clarify the purpose and context, perhaps by focusing on settings like pools or scuba diving.

With two weeks to go, we’re eager to see how this takes shape.